Okay, since last week was apparently "sharp things" week for
friends and friends of
friends, let me bring out this odd looking thing that got a fair amount of use this weekend.
It's called a "WSK" or "Wilderness Survival Knife" (also "Tracker") - and was I believe the result of a collaboration between a custom knifemaker and a wilderness survival instructor a few years back. And yes, it was in a
movie*.
Some have called this pattern a useless overpriced gimmick, often throwing in some "Rambo" jokes to boot. Others will sing its praises to the heavens. Me? Well obviously I was intrigued enough to try buying a decent example of the breed** shortly before coming to Alaska. And so far, I'm really impressed with it.
Yes, it looks like a bad fantasy movie reject. Sawteeth and holes and different grind angles every whichaway. However, each and every one of those odd looking things is there for a reason. I'll not bother repeating the whys and the wherefores - those are
easily available elsewhere on the
web. Suffice it to say though - they
do make a positive difference in the functional utility of the knife.
The key is... it's very much a niche thing. Within that niche - namely "easily, conveniently, and discreetly carried tool for making *other* improvised tools in an extended wooded wilderness survival situation" - it's fantastic. Quite possibly even unsurpassed. Yes, I mean that last part.
Outside of that niche, its utility drops off sharply.
As an example - the hosts of the Halloween gathering I went to this weekend have an informal "Alaska Challenge" - part race, part wilderness survival exercise. One of the requirements this time around was the creation or discovery of 'tools.'
Within two hours, that WSK and a small tree had given our team:
* trimmed bark strips for a basket
* a roughed-out flatbow stave
* shelter supports
* a figure-four trap
* a sharpened digging stick
... and prolly a couple other things I'm forgetting. And it made making all those things
easy.
A small axe, drawshave, and camping knife would have done much the same job at least as well - but would have been more cumbersome. In contrast, the WSK sits sideways across the small of the back, neatly out of the way. A solidly built smaller hunting knife would been moderately easier to carry, but the jobs would have been much harder and time-consuming. And honestly, given the work at hand I suspect one of the little Mora knives I've had recommended to me as "more realistic" would have snapped, as would many (not all, to be sure) folders.
The WSK is a compromise - everything is. I'm no professional wilderness survival expert, not by any stretch - but I have learned this much: anytime you take something with you into the woods, you're trading weight for time. The highly skilled woodsman can improvise most anything he'd need - knap a stone blade, assemble a shelter, twist cordage or weave containers. If you're really serious, you can make the tools to make the tools to make the tools - I've known guys who could turn iron-bearing river sand into a swordblade.
But every one of those actions takes time, as well as being dependent on locally available materials***. Time spent Making Stuff is time not spent closing on a destination, signaling for help, or whatever else it is you want to be doing that got you into a wilderness survival situation in the first place. And so you make a trade - you carry a tent and sleeping bag so you don't need to spend a couple hours making a good shelter each night. You carry a blast lighter and matches and suchlike so you don't need to fuss with making a bowdrill. Everything is a tradeoff.
The WSK fits squarely in the "carry a minimum of stuff... but be ready to improvise nearly everything you need for days or weeks" point on that continuum.
If you're in the mostly settled parts of the lower 48 where a ten mile walk in any direction can get you to a road, which can in turn get you to a filling station and nice comfy hotel - then yes, the WSK is probably overkill. If you're off to set up a basecamp somewhere and you're taking an assortment of dedicated tools - it's probably going to be unused weight.
But here and now? Within that niche? Let's just say were I ever to be dropped in the wilds with a single tool**** - it would be this one. No question about it.

* In the movie, it was used mostly as a scary-looking gimmick knife for the hero and villain to cut each other up with. Despite looking intimidating as all heck, I don't expect though that it would make a particularly good weapon. The almost hatchet-like balance, along with the projections all over just make the thing feel clumsy compared to the fighting knives some friends of mine own. But better than nothing in a pinch I suppose.
** No I don't personally think the TOPS version is a particularly good example of the breed, but I'll leave that decision to you. Mine is from Mark Terrel of
MTKnives and I could not be more pleased. I did have to smooth off one finger ridge that didn't fit my hand quite right, but so far as "quality per dollar spent" I don't think it's possible to do better.
*** Hence my saying
wooded wilderness survival tool. Note most of those chores I mentioned involved woodwork. If you're more concerned about weaving grass and sculpting clay water vessels, I doubt it will be much use to you.
**** A situation which although unlikely, remains distinctly within the realm of possibility flying about up here. The only thing it's really missing is a firestarter.. which is why there's a little one in that tin you see on the sheath.